Talk:Rhea Scout/@comment-1330392-20181201174735/@comment-38556904-20190217194234

I do and I don't. I play Tabletop games and I've been characters of all spectrums (I prefer Neutral Evil). I don't think that choosing to keep the treasure you find as a scout is inherently wrong, especially not if your team is getting paid based on their completion of the quest. Like you said; he's the Scout and with that job, comes risk and rewards. That being said, there are rules to the Guild (stupid as some of them are) and he chose to break one. Now, while I disagree to the extent of the punishment, I do think a single rank demotion was in order. Expulsion from the town and a 2 rank demotion for lying about where you got some treasure, especially when no one was hurt in the process of you acquiring it, was extremely overkill. Her insulting the guy by calling him stupid was also unnecessary. Truth be told, I wouldn't have minded him killing her for that.