Talk:Rhea Scout/@comment-38556904-20191201211547/@comment-38556904-20191202173302

Hey Raider Z! Sorry! I didn't realize to continue replying I had to click the reply to my original comment.

I never said Guild Girl did anything wrong. By punishing The Scout based on the rules of the Guild, she's in the right, all day, every day. When Rhea Scout tried to kill her and got killed, he deserved that. When he got his punishment, he deserved that too.

All I'm saying is that I think that her "are you stupid?" Comment didn't help the situation. I think THAT was unwarranted and not a wise thing to do. Everything else she said was fair. Maybe the "I don't think so" when he said you'll be sorry, but that's in retrospect. After all, how was she to know he'd be about that murdering life?

My thing is that she felt she needed a guard (for whatever reason) when she was dealing with him. That makes him dangerous, how dangerous can be subjective. The point is that while she certainly CAN talk to people the way she did, she might wanna slow her roll on the "are you stupid?" parts. Goblin Slayer won't always be around and some people don't take too kindly to punishments and or snarky comments.

As for the alignment thing, that's more for DnD. Chaotic Neutral people do steal. Typically, DnD labels you "evil" when you start murdering. Trying to skim past the rules and keep some gear CAN be considered evil, but it could also be considered Neutral, as well. After all, Jack Sparrow is Chaotic Neutral and he's not above stealing. Yuffie as well. That's all I meant by that. I wasn't ready to label Rhea as evil until he actually attempted a legit evil thing, but I could understand how he could be labeled as evil for his theft.

As for the "slap her until she cried" part, I didn't see that. I assume it was in the manga cause I don't recall that being in the anime and the anime didn't get to where he tries to kill her. He would be in the wrong for saying that, but I admit, giving her the 5 Finger Blessing for the "are you stupid?" Comment would've been funny to me.

Then again, I'm not a big fan of Guild Girl, so that's me being biased against a character I don't really care for.

I don't think that Rhea Scout is in the right for anything, BUT I can also understand how her comment might've given him extra motivation to try to kill Guild Girl. I do think the punishment was excessive, but Guild Girl doesn't make the rules, she just enforces them. Still, if she's going to punish people and call them stupid, warranted or not, she might want to invest in a body guard.