User blog:SnakeDX/What really happened to these characters.

I decided to check out some websites for Goblin Slayer reviews and came upon the long running Anime News Network. Out of curiosity I decided to check the comment section of the reviews to see what people thought. The latest comments showed 2 guys arguing over whether or not Fighter from Priestess' original party survived and the all female party in the forest fortress were raped before being brutally killed.

One of the guys in question seemed kinda triggered because the other guy said the female party was raped. The first guy showed links to pages of the light novel's first volume which does not clearly state that Fighter survived although the manga and anime shows that she did. As for the female party the anime only shows them naked but IIRC the manga shows one of them being raped while the LN only suggests they were toyed with and not explicitly stated otherwise. The other guy though suggests that they were raped or at least the leader was before being killed.

To summarize, I'd like some opinions from everyone on which is right in this case? The guy who says Fighter died and the female party was killed without being raped or the other guy who said that Fighter survived and the female party was raped? Seems like a pointless argument at first but it got intense and one of the mods got involved so it got me curious. Opinions are fine but pls keep it civil. I dont wanna see what happened there happen here too.

For those who are curious or want to read what went down heres a link. The entire thing only lasted for about 6-7 posts before mod stepped in and all this happened today.

https://www.animenewsnetwork.com/bbs/phpBB2/viewtopic.php?t=3087636&postdays=0&postorder=asc&start=225